Grey’s Anatomy delivers on its promise of adding a new gay chaplain in Season 21.
Episode 2 of the season, “Take Me to Church,” introduces James, played by Michael Thomas Grant, Grey Sloan’s new chaplain.
The move comes on the heels of Jake Borelli‘s impending exit from the series.
Funnily enough, Levi is the person James interacts with the most. Levi does not take to him well because both men have varying philosophies.
The character raised some curiosity when he was announced because people do not see gay chaplains daily.
The character description teases personal struggles when “James finds himself at a crossroads where he is open to love and taking great leaps of faith.”
The episode does not touch on his personal life, but there is plenty to engage in his interactions with Levi.
Levi and James Go Head to Head in Grey’s Anatomy
Levi is a doctor who trusts based on evidence and science. James is a clergyman who believes without much evidence but connects with people more than the average person.
Their point of contention arises when they have different ideas about how to treat Cal, a young patient.
The patient has a rare genetic condition that predisposes him to cancer, and in fact, he has developed one.
James “holds a special place in his heart for his younger patients,” which explains why he fights for them.
James tries to have him make peace with the situation so that his death might not scare him so much.
Levi is hellbent on finding a cure and thinks having the kid look at potential coffins is giving up too early and feels insulted by it.
There is no clear winner in this situation. It all depends on the patient. They both make a strong case for fighting or embracing fate.
The reality is the patient will die, but they can play a part in making sure his remaining time on earth is not painful and miserable.
Levi fails to see this until the very end. However, he eventually sees James’ point.
Enemies to Lovers?
Seeing them interact, one can’t help but see the potential in a James and Levi relationship.
Enemies to lovers is a trope that never gets old. Unfortunately, this doesn’t seem like it would work with Levi set to leave Grey Sloan.
It would be an exercise in futility. Also, remember James’ “crossroads?” It sounds like a crisis of faith and sexuality.
Whether James gets into a relationship sooner or later remains to be seen.
The character’s introduction is solid, establishing his philosophy and convictions.
There are some terrible traps Grey’s Anatomy might fall into with this character, including sidelining him since he’s not part of the core medical team, but we reserve judgment.
Grey’s Anatomy Season 21, Thursdays at 10 p.m. on ABC.